Taking Right-Wing Economic Populism Seriously
It’s easy to write-off batshit crazy narcissists like Dick Armey and Sarah Palin as what they are: Batshit crazy narcissists. But as Wellstone Action’s Jeff Blodgett reminds us in this blog post, Armey/Palin-ism does represent something real and potentially powerful, even if it is insane.
Blodgett is a former aide and campaign manager for Paul Wellstone, so he knows a little bit about progressive movement building and the double-edged sword that is populism. Here’s what he sees:
ECONOMIC CONSERVATIVES ARE IN ASCENDANCE — growing in influence and setting strategy for the right. The social religious wing, dominant in the Bush administration, has become less effective and relevant. Their message is angry, populist, and economic: FreedomWorks’ slogan is: Lower Taxes, Less Government, More Freedom. Government takeover is their bogeyman. In 2010, they will focus on exploiting the economic pain in the country, railing against spending and taxes, and blaming all government and certain incumbents.CONSERVATIVES ARE BORROWING FROM THE PROGRESSIVE MOVEMENT. The NYT article quotes FreedomWorks staff saying that they are making close study of Saul Alinsky and other community organizers. Like progressives, the other side is increasing conservative candidate development (NY-23 and in GOP primaries all over the country), and improving their grassroots advocacy skills (like the impression made at August town halls).
THE CONSERVATIVE MOVEMENT CONTINUES TO BE BETTER FUNDED. FreedomWorks, just one of many groups, easily raised $7 million from donors in 2008, including single gifts of $1 million and $750,000. The Leadership Institute, the premier training center for the right, sustains an $8 million dollar annual budget–at least twice the budget of any of comparable groups (like Wellstone Action) on the progressive side. Americans for Prosperity, another key conservative economic group has 73 staff people nationally and in 20 states.
In the short term, of course, this frothing movement may temporarily self-destruct by virtue of being publicly represented by incoherent and politically unpalatable freaks like Armey and Palin. But in the long term, it’s scary stuff, because it represents one expression of authentic anger in the country at large.
As I wrote in my book, The Uprising, populism is value neutral – there’s conservative populism and there’s progressive populism; there’s productive populism and there’s destructive populism. And so a battle is on right now between the Right and Left to offer an enraged America a populist way to channel its justifiable anger.
Progressives can win this fight – but we face some disadvantages, not the least of which is that a cautious and sometimes corrupt Democratic Party has become the Washington Establishment via its overwhelming wins in 2006 and 2008. That means it becomes harder to harness anti-establishment fervor in a backlash election climate.
It doesn’t, however, mean we cannot defeat the Armey/Palin phenomenon. On almost every issue, the right is way out of step with America. In that sense, our charge is simply delivering on the progressive promises we’ve been making, while their charge is the much more difficult task of convincing/misleading America into supporting positions the country doesn’t already support.
That’s why those who berate progressive pressure against Obama and Democrats are so wrong in their outlook. If we don’t mount that pressure and Democrats therefore do not deliver, we will help build the Armey/Palin movement into something even more dangerous.
Related posts:
- Welcome to The Uprising: Yes, Populism “Will Take Right-Wing and Left-Wing Forms” In a typical Establishment-worshiping, populism-is-bad platitude-as-serious-article from The New Republic...
- CNN on the Rise of Left-Right Populism I appeared on CNN on Friday for a one-on-one interview...
- Who Woulda Thunk It? Populism Is Popular! How, in a self-described democracy, is it possible for the...
- What is populism and why are Democrats afraid of it? Michael Moore's latest film and Alan Grayson's "die quickly" speech...
- What is Populism? (Part II) Last week’s post, “What is Populism and Why are Democrats...
